A joint research team from Professor Masaya Toda of the Graduate School of Engineering at Tohoku University and the Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research in Germany conducted experiments in which water drops hit a superhydrophobic mesh to produce charged microdroplets (charged spray). In a paper published on November 17, 2026, in the journal Physics of Fluids, the team examined in detail how drop impact speed and the mesh's pore structure affect the amount of charge, and analyzed the charging mechanism.

The study clarified the conditions under which charge is generated as drops break up, as well as design guidelines for controlling it. In particular, the researchers confirmed that the charge per unit mass of spray and the total charge change in different ways, a finding that matters for applications to raindrop power generation. On the other hand, the electric power recovered in the experiments was extremely small, and the durability of the surface remains a challenge.

AD

How Drops Passing Through a Superhydrophobic Mesh Become Charged

It has long been known that electric charge appears in the air around waterfalls and on seashores where waves spray. When a water drop shatters into tiny droplets, positive and negative charges separate. The research team, including Professor Masaya Toda, Professor Hans-Jürgen Butt of the Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research, and Dr. Rutvik Lathia, reproduced this phenomenon in the laboratory and investigated the conditions that govern the charging.

The findings were published as the peer-reviewed paper "Drop spray electrification" in Physics of Fluids, Volume 38, Issue 11 (2026, DOI: 10.1063/5.0355532). According to Tohoku University's press release, the paper was published on November 17, 2026. The authors had earlier made the work public on the preprint server arXiv on August 6.

To examine the charged spray produced when drops pass through the mesh, the experiments combined charge measurement with a Faraday cup and imaging with a high-speed camera. The main sample was a conductive steel mesh with an opening size of 400 micrometers and a wire diameter of 330 micrometers. Its surface carried a superhydrophobic soot-based coating that strongly repels water. The team dropped 25-microliter water drops onto this mesh and measured the motion and charge of the droplets after impact.

Before the measurements, the researchers also confirmed that the drops were not charged before impact. In a control experiment in which drops fell from a grounded needle, no detectable residual charge was found on the drops before impact. The detection limit of the measurement system is 0.1 picocoulombs (pC). The team interprets the charge observed beneath the mesh as having been generated by contact and separation between the drops and the mesh.

An important metric in this study is the "charge-to-mass ratio (pC/mg)." This is the charge of the collected spray divided by its mass, and it indicates how much charge is contained per unit mass of spray. It is not the same as energy conversion efficiency, which indicates how much of the input kinetic energy could be converted into electrical energy.

Four Drop Breakup Patterns Depending on Impact Speed

The behavior of a drop hitting the mesh can be organized using a dimensionless quantity called the Weber number (We). The Weber number is the ratio of a drop's inertial force to its surface tension, and indicates how readily the drop deforms and breaks up on impact. The team used drops about 3.65 millimeters in diameter and adjusted the Weber number by changing the falling speed. As a result, for this combination of drop and mesh, the spray generation process was found to divide into four regimes depending on impact conditions.

Weber number Spray generation process Charging behavior
Below We 20 (below penetration threshold) No optically detectable secondary spray is produced Measured charge is within the electrometer noise range
Around We 25 A "rebound jet," formed as the drop spreads, then contracts and bounces back, produces the spray A small amount of spray shows a high charge-to-mass ratio
We 30–75 Both an "impact-induced jet" right after impact and the subsequent "rebound jet" occur The charge-to-mass ratio reaches about 6 pC/mg at We 30, then declines
Above We 75 Pancake-shaped bouncing suppresses the rebound jet, and impact-induced penetration dominates The charge-to-mass ratio approaches about 0.5 pC/mg, and the total charge peaks around We 100

Below We 20, the drop did not pass through the mesh, and no spray was seen even with the high-speed camera. The measured charge also stayed within the electrometer's noise range. As impact speed increases to around We 25, the drop spreads laterally over the mesh and then bounces back while contracting toward its center under surface tension. At this point, the "rebound jet" pushed out through the pores generates spray.

At We 30–75, an "impact-induced jet," in which water passes through the pores immediately after impact, also occurs. Both this impact-induced jet and the later rebound jet contribute to spray generation. Above We 75, "pancake bouncing" occurs, in which the drop rebounds from a widely flattened state. This suppresses the rebound jet, and the jet from penetration right after impact becomes the main route of spray generation.

Notably, the charge-to-mass ratio does not simply rise as impact speed increases. It reached about 6 pC/mg near We 30, then declined with increasing impact speed and approached about 0.5 pC/mg. This is because, as the impact becomes more violent, the mass of spray produced increases sharply while the total charge carried away does not increase at the same rate.

Total charge, meanwhile, peaked around We 100 and changed only gradually up to We 500. However, the standard deviation of the measurements was large at We 100–500, so the team does not consider the total charge to have fully saturated. The team interprets the main cause of charging as contact and separation at the solid-liquid interface inside and around the mesh pores. However, whether the carriers of the transferred charge are ions or electrons, and their specific transfer pathways, have not been identified.

AD

Mesh Size and Conductivity Affect Charge Amount and Stability

The team also ran comparison experiments varying the mesh's opening size, wire diameter, and material. They found that meshes with smaller openings and thinner wires tended to produce spray with a higher charge-to-mass ratio. When drops pass through a finer mesh, the conditions for liquid-solid contact and separation change, which is thought to affect the amount of charge.

The conductivity of the mesh also strongly affected the stability of charging under repeated impacts. With a conductive metal mesh, the charge left on the mesh after a drop departs escapes through the ground path, so residual charge can be reduced before the next drop hits. As a result, relatively stable charging was maintained even with repeated drop impacts.

By contrast, with an insulating polypropylene mesh, charge accumulated on the surface did not easily escape and remained for a long time. Because charge from the previous impact was still present when the next drop hit, charge separation at the solid-liquid interface was affected, and the charging behavior became unstable.

These results show that controlling charging with a superhydrophobic mesh depends on the opening size, wire diameter, substrate conductivity, and impact conditions expressed by the Weber number. However, the conditions that maximize the charge-to-mass ratio do not necessarily coincide with those that maximize total charge or recovered power. Even if a fine mesh and suitable impact speed raise the charge per unit mass, the power that can actually be recovered also depends on how much spray is produced and how the charge is collected.

About 28 Nanowatts Recovered, and the Coating Degrades After 1,000 Impacts

The team also conducted a supplementary experiment to recover electric power from the generated charged spray. When the charge of the collected spray was passed through a load resistor and measured, output peaked at a load resistance of 1 gigaohm (GΩ), yielding a value equivalent to about 28 nanowatts (nW) per gram of collected spray.

The authors acknowledge that this output is small compared with existing droplet generators optimized for power recovery. However, the experimental setup was designed not to maximize power generation but to clarify spray generation and the charging mechanism.

In the field of droplet-based power generation, there are studies that have reported higher outputs. For example, a review paper published in 2024 reports a peak power density of up to 82.66 W/m² for a hybrid droplet generator using a single water drop. However, this value indicates peak power per unit area, and its metric differs from the "about 28 nW per gram of spray" in this study. Device structures and measurement conditions also differ, so power generation performance cannot be compared by the numbers alone. The same review also points out that droplet power generation research lacks unified evaluation criteria, with voltage, current, peak power, transferred charge, energy conversion efficiency, and other measures reported under differing conditions.

The durability of the superhydrophobic coating is also an important issue for practical use. When the team made water drops hit the same spot 1,000 times, the charge of the spray decreased. At the same time, visible damage appeared in the coating, which has a fine hierarchical surface structure, and a decline in water repellency was also observed. Specifically, the static contact angle of the surface decreased, and the roll-off angle, the angle at which a drop begins to slide off, increased. This indicates that repeated drop impacts degrade the surface, which also affects long-term charging performance.

This study clarified the physical mechanisms for controlling droplet breakup and charging using a superhydrophobic mesh. As challenges toward power generation applications, the authors cite increasing the flux, meaning the number of droplets impacting per unit time, enlarging the charge-receiving area, optimizing charge recovery methods, and integrating with electrostatic induction and triboelectric nanogenerators (TENGs).

Furthermore, because the size, falling speed, and impact position of drops in natural rain are not constant, it is difficult to apply laboratory conditions directly. To operate a raindrop-based generator over the long term, it will be necessary to develop wear-resistant superhydrophobic surfaces and to design circuits and structures that efficiently collect the tiny charges generated.